D.C. fights SeatGeek and Vivid Seats over its 10% ticket resale cap

Washington, D.C., wants a federal judge to keep its ticket resale price cap in place despite a legal fight from SeatGeek, Vivid Seats, TickPick, and Gametime. The four sites, backed by Ticket Policy Forum, want the rules put on hold while their case plays out.

Under the RESALE Act, scalpers can charge just 10% above a ticket's first sale price, with taxes and fees counted. Resale sites get a separate fee cap of 10%. Buyers must also see the first price. These limits apply to concerts and stage events, but most sports games and films get a pass.

And the math has the platforms mad. A $40 concert seat could fetch $44 at most, with just $4 in service fees. They claim that amount would fail to pay the cost of each sale. Less than 1% of their covered deals had both parties based in D.C., which adds to their legal gripe.

Their case also claims that D.C. is trying to police sales far past its borders while giving local firms an edge. The group wants the whole act struck out, not just parts of it. If the court rejects that bid, they also seek payment for what they call a loss of property rights, without naming a dollar amount.

D.C. has little patience for that stance. Its lawyers say the sites tried to turn a policy dispute into a rights case after they failed to sway lawmakers. The council backed the act with no dissent, Mayor Muriel Bowser signed it, and Congress let it stand.

Here's another snag for the resale sites. Even if Judge Carl Nichols bars D.C. officials from using the law, fans could still sue sellers under local trade rules. That means a court win on the first step might not spare the sites from legal risk.

Ticket price data is another sore spot. The firms say they cannot always check what a seat first cost. D.C. says its watchdog will accept a good-faith estimate, and sites can reject a sale when the price is unclear. No rule forces them to list each ticket.

As for the sports and movie carveouts, D.C. points to how often fans get a chance to attend. Teams host many games, and films run across theaters. A touring act may visit the city just once. That difference is the basis for the special limits on live shows.

The cash claims face pushback as well. D.C. argues that any losses could be paid back if the sites win their case. These are national firms, after all, and the city sees no proof that one local cap could cause deep harm to their wider trade.

StubHub got dragged into the debate despite not being a direct plaintiff. Its $1.75 billion in annual sales came with $971.7 million spent on marketing and sales. D.C. uses that split to cast doubt on claims that resale fees merely pay for basic service costs and fair profit.

Meanwhile, another suit from the National Association of Ticketing Professionals and two resellers seeks to kill only the markup limit. D.C. says the split between the two cases hurts the case for a broad court ban.

Other states offer some context. Maine and Vermont have adopted caps, while Rhode Island has long had markup limits. California tried a 10% rule for small independent venues, but the bill failed. Over $1 million from StubHub's lobbying budget went to TPF.

Even Donald Trump has called out harsh ticket fees in a federal order. Live Nation, the parent firm of Ticketmaster, also backs resale caps. But TPF chief Brian Berry warns that D.C.'s plan may push deals away from legal sites while leaving first-sale platforms exempt.

The next call rests with Judge Nichols. The resale firms want a decision before the act takes effect, giving them room to appeal if they lose. For fans, the case centers on whether D.C. can curb ticket markups without crossing legal limits.
 

Attachments

  • D.C. fights SeatGeek and Vivid Seats over its 10% ticket resale cap.webp
    D.C. fights SeatGeek and Vivid Seats over its 10% ticket resale cap.webp
    283.8 KB · Views: 2

Sponsored

Top