NVIDIA's investment arm is fighting a court demand from Universal Music Group and Sony Music Entertainment over Suno. NVentures wants out of a sworn interview in the AI music copyright case, despite handing over 6,324 files spanning 28,194 pages. The firm says its cash stake gives the labels no right to grill it.
The legal fight sits in a California federal court, while the main Suno case runs through Boston. NVentures wants the subpoena thrown out or cut back to a far smaller set of questions. Its lawyers say the labels have yet to point out any gaps in the records already shared.
Here's the core dispute. UMG, Capitol Records, and Sony accuse Suno of using their music to train its AI models without permission. They also claim Suno took audio from YouTube by bypassing download limits. Warner Music Group was once part of the case but later made a deal with Suno.
The cash risk is no joke. One suit covers 560 recordings, with up to $150,000 at stake for each willful breach. That puts the maximum claim at $84 million. Another case adds 60,202 tracks, raising the possible total by over $9 billion, though neither figure is an actual award.
And the labels seek as much as $2,500 per alleged breach of YouTube's download safeguards. Those claims add another layer to a case that already has major sums in dispute.
NVentures says it was not part of Suno's data choices, model design, or app operations. It joined as a minority investor after the first case had begun. The firm also has no board seat, observer role, or advisory post at Suno. Just a financial stake.
The labels first sought answers across 13 areas. Two were dropped, and one shifted to a written check of the records. Ten remain, covering talks with Suno, due diligence, training data, legal risk, growth plans, and possible license costs.
There is also a fight over private business data. NVentures argues that its internal reviews are not fair game for a case about what Suno did. Its view is that Suno should answer for its tech, while industry experts can deal with market impact.
Lightspeed Venture Partners has a similar court dispute, though its role is quite different. The firm led Suno's Series B and holds a board seat, according to the labels. UMG and Sony say investor files can help show what Suno knew about legal risk and whether any alleged infringement was deliberate.
Menlo Ventures has been pulled in as well. A judge cleared the labels to question former executive C.C. Gong about a deleted social post in which she had said she shifted much of her music listening to Suno.
The investor money behind Suno is huge. Its Series C brought in $250 million at a $2.45 billion valuation, with Menlo, NVentures, Hallwood Media, Lightspeed, and Matrix taking part. A later Series D raised over $400 million and valued the firm at $5.4 billion. NVentures says it made no further bet.
A past ruling in the Udio case may matter here. Judge Kandis A. Westmore made Andreessen Horowitz hand over files, citing its direct board ties to Udio. NVentures argues that its lack of such ties puts it in a different class.
NVIDIA Corporation has also asked a judge to block its separate sworn interview. Both NVIDIA firms have the same legal team, and the labels still have a chance to respond before the court rules.
The odd twist is that UMG has a separate AI music deal with NVIDIA. That project uses Music Flamingo, with NVIDIA executive Richard Kerris stressing artist rights, credit, and copyright safeguards. The firms can work together on AI tools while their lawyers clash over Suno.
The legal fight sits in a California federal court, while the main Suno case runs through Boston. NVentures wants the subpoena thrown out or cut back to a far smaller set of questions. Its lawyers say the labels have yet to point out any gaps in the records already shared.
Here's the core dispute. UMG, Capitol Records, and Sony accuse Suno of using their music to train its AI models without permission. They also claim Suno took audio from YouTube by bypassing download limits. Warner Music Group was once part of the case but later made a deal with Suno.
The cash risk is no joke. One suit covers 560 recordings, with up to $150,000 at stake for each willful breach. That puts the maximum claim at $84 million. Another case adds 60,202 tracks, raising the possible total by over $9 billion, though neither figure is an actual award.
And the labels seek as much as $2,500 per alleged breach of YouTube's download safeguards. Those claims add another layer to a case that already has major sums in dispute.
NVentures says it was not part of Suno's data choices, model design, or app operations. It joined as a minority investor after the first case had begun. The firm also has no board seat, observer role, or advisory post at Suno. Just a financial stake.
The labels first sought answers across 13 areas. Two were dropped, and one shifted to a written check of the records. Ten remain, covering talks with Suno, due diligence, training data, legal risk, growth plans, and possible license costs.
There is also a fight over private business data. NVentures argues that its internal reviews are not fair game for a case about what Suno did. Its view is that Suno should answer for its tech, while industry experts can deal with market impact.
Lightspeed Venture Partners has a similar court dispute, though its role is quite different. The firm led Suno's Series B and holds a board seat, according to the labels. UMG and Sony say investor files can help show what Suno knew about legal risk and whether any alleged infringement was deliberate.
Menlo Ventures has been pulled in as well. A judge cleared the labels to question former executive C.C. Gong about a deleted social post in which she had said she shifted much of her music listening to Suno.
The investor money behind Suno is huge. Its Series C brought in $250 million at a $2.45 billion valuation, with Menlo, NVentures, Hallwood Media, Lightspeed, and Matrix taking part. A later Series D raised over $400 million and valued the firm at $5.4 billion. NVentures says it made no further bet.
A past ruling in the Udio case may matter here. Judge Kandis A. Westmore made Andreessen Horowitz hand over files, citing its direct board ties to Udio. NVentures argues that its lack of such ties puts it in a different class.
NVIDIA Corporation has also asked a judge to block its separate sworn interview. Both NVIDIA firms have the same legal team, and the labels still have a chance to respond before the court rules.
The odd twist is that UMG has a separate AI music deal with NVIDIA. That project uses Music Flamingo, with NVIDIA executive Richard Kerris stressing artist rights, credit, and copyright safeguards. The firms can work together on AI tools while their lawyers clash over Suno.