EVOX sued ByteDance over 7,095 photos allegedly used to train Seedream

ByteDance faces a copyright lawsuit over 7,095 car photos that EVOX Productions says helped train its Seedream AI image tool. The California firm claims TikTok's parent took its work without a license, then built a system that can make near copies for pennies.

A court in Central California has the case. EVOX says a check of its website logs exposed the alleged downloads from EvoxStock.com. Its filing lays out the images and their copyright records in an exhibit that spans about 100 pages.

And this is not some small photo archive. EVOX has spent three decades shooting thousands of car types, with more than two million pictures under copyright. The firm, based in Chino, sells image rights to car businesses and buyers who need shots of a given model.

The cash gap is wild. EVOX puts its spending on the archive at about $56 million, while a single photo license can cost over $1,300. It still earns millions each year from that trade, but claims cheap AI copies could hurt demand for its work.

Then there is the visual proof EVOX wants the court to weigh. Its filing pairs real photos with Seedream 4.5 results for a 2021 Audi Sportback Premium Plus, a 2021 Audi TT Coupe, and a 2021 Chevrolet Silverado. The firm says the AI can mimic its shot angles, lights, white sets, and soft car shadows.

EVOX also points to ByteDance's notes on Seedream 4.0. Those papers discuss using web data to create image pairs for AI training. The photographer argues that this points to mass web collection, though the cited wording does not prove that ByteDance took those exact files.

Here is the legal twist. EVOX claims the AI model itself holds math-based copies of protected art, making Seedream an unlawful work derived from its photos. That is a claim about the model, not just what users get when they type a prompt.

Even if ByteDance blames its users, EVOX has another claim ready. It argues that the tech firm knew people could make copies and had the means to curb that use. The suit alleges that ByteDance chose not to act because paid Seedream access brings in cash.

The damages could get quite large. EVOX seeks the highest sum allowed for willful copyright misuse, up to $150,000 per work. If all 7,095 shots count on their own, the math tops $1 billion. But that outcome is far from certain.

Many photos share group copyright records, which may affect how a judge counts each work. EVOX argues that each image has value on its own. It could also seek proven losses and ByteDance's gains instead, along with interest and court costs. No firm total appears in the claim.

Notably, EVOX has not asked the judge to shut Seedream down. The case is about alleged copying, AI training, and the harm the firm says follows from cheap lookalike images.

There is some awkward context for ByteDance. The firm made a global deal with the Motion Picture Association to add rights safeguards for Seedream and its video tool, Seedance. That pact followed a legal warning over Seedream 5.0 Lite and Seedance 2.0.

John Rogovin, ByteDance's top lawyer, backed AI development with strong creator rights when the pact was made. EVOX cites that stance and argues that small rights holders have not had the same care. That is its view, not a court finding.

Meanwhile, EVOX has gone after several AI firms. Stability AI, Runway AI, Hugging Face, and DeviantArt faced claims tied to over 100,000 photo links in data used for Stable Diffusion. Google and Midjourney have also faced similar suits from the firm.

The wider legal debate reaches music AI as well. A Munich court sided with GEMA over lyrics that ChatGPT models could store and repeat. OpenAI appealed. That court also ruled for GEMA in a suit against Suno over music use, though Suno disputes the result.

ByteDance has music AI plans of its own through Seed-Music. For this case, though, the focus is on car photos and whether AI training crossed a copyright line. The court still has to decide if EVOX can prove its claims.
 

Attachments

  • EVOX sued ByteDance over 7,095 photos allegedly used to train Seedream.webp
    EVOX sued ByteDance over 7,095 photos allegedly used to train Seedream.webp
    283.8 KB · Views: 1

Sponsored

Top