Snoopy & The Great Mystery Club publisher GameMill Entertainment has reached a deal to settle a music copyright suit. Lee Mendelson Film Productions (LMFP) had accused the firm of using tracks that came far too close to the work of Vince Guaraldi.
In New York, federal Judge Denise Cote closed the case after both parties told her they had worked out a deal in principle. Either party can still seek to revive it before the deadline. The cash terms remain private, and no court has ruled on the alleged copying.
The dispute came down to two Peanuts tunes, Linus and Lucy and Skating. LMFP handles the publishing rights, while GameMill had cleared the cartoon cast through Peanuts Worldwide. The music rights were a separate deal, and LMFP claimed the publisher skipped that part.
Here is where it gets messy. LMFP alleged that GameMill hired people to make new tracks close to Guaraldi's work, rather than use the real pieces. Its claim was that fans might take those sounds for the music from the TV specials.
Andy Koehler, GameMill's publishing chief, had described the audio work as an attempt to stay true to the Peanuts style. LMFP cited his remarks as proof that the publisher knew the work it was accused of copying.
Then came the music review. Dr. Ethan Lustig, a music expert hired by LMFP, checked 4.5 hours of gameplay. He logged 192 uses of 17 distinct cues, which filled 92.6% of the video. Of those cues, 15 had strong links to one or both Guaraldi pieces, he said.
Those 15 cues made up 89.6% of the footage. Two versions of a Success theme also came up 34 times, each tied to a player clearing a task. LMFP argued that this made a tune akin to Guaraldi's famous work part of the game's reward system.
For context, the title came out on PS5, Xbox Series X|S, Nintendo Switch, and PC, with a Switch 2 release later. Its standard copy cost $39.99, while the deluxe one went for $49.99, based on the court filing.
LMFP sought more than $300,000 in damages and a ban on further use of the disputed music. As another route, it could ask for statutory damages of $150,000 per song if it proved willful misuse. That meant a $300,000 cap on that claim, with legal fees sought apart from it.
And GameMill was not the sole target. The suit also named up to 10 unidentified people who may have made or worked on the audio. None of the claims reached a final ruling, given the pending deal.
Elsewhere, LMFP had filed claims against Heritage Auctions, Buckle-Down Inc., and the US Department of the Interior. Two of those disputes led to payments. Buckle-Down agreed to $27,500, and the federal government agreed to $20,000.
Heritage Auctions faced a claim over a social media use of Linus and Lucy, much like Buckle-Down. The government case dealt with Guaraldi's version of O Tannenbaum in an online holiday card. Heritage later got a pause in court deadlines while both sides tried to reach terms.
CBS took a different path. It made a license deal after Linus and Lucy aired during the final episode of The Late Show with Stephen Colbert. Funds from that deal are set for World Central Kitchen, a charity that feeds people in need.
LMFP chairman Jason Mendelson has framed these cases as a push for written music licenses in business use. Attorney Marc Jacobson also made clear that the firm intends to defend the value and rights tied to Guaraldi's work.
One key detail is that Peanuts Worldwide had no role as a defendant. Sony Music Entertainment (Japan) and Sony Pictures Entertainment later gained majority control of its parent, Peanuts Holdings, taking Sony Group's stake from 39% to 80%.
LMFP itself dates back to Lee Mendelson, the late producer behind the Peanuts TV specials. His company remains tied to the music legacy of those shows, though the GameMill deal leaves the main copyright question unanswered.
In New York, federal Judge Denise Cote closed the case after both parties told her they had worked out a deal in principle. Either party can still seek to revive it before the deadline. The cash terms remain private, and no court has ruled on the alleged copying.
The dispute came down to two Peanuts tunes, Linus and Lucy and Skating. LMFP handles the publishing rights, while GameMill had cleared the cartoon cast through Peanuts Worldwide. The music rights were a separate deal, and LMFP claimed the publisher skipped that part.
Here is where it gets messy. LMFP alleged that GameMill hired people to make new tracks close to Guaraldi's work, rather than use the real pieces. Its claim was that fans might take those sounds for the music from the TV specials.
Andy Koehler, GameMill's publishing chief, had described the audio work as an attempt to stay true to the Peanuts style. LMFP cited his remarks as proof that the publisher knew the work it was accused of copying.
Then came the music review. Dr. Ethan Lustig, a music expert hired by LMFP, checked 4.5 hours of gameplay. He logged 192 uses of 17 distinct cues, which filled 92.6% of the video. Of those cues, 15 had strong links to one or both Guaraldi pieces, he said.
Those 15 cues made up 89.6% of the footage. Two versions of a Success theme also came up 34 times, each tied to a player clearing a task. LMFP argued that this made a tune akin to Guaraldi's famous work part of the game's reward system.
For context, the title came out on PS5, Xbox Series X|S, Nintendo Switch, and PC, with a Switch 2 release later. Its standard copy cost $39.99, while the deluxe one went for $49.99, based on the court filing.
LMFP sought more than $300,000 in damages and a ban on further use of the disputed music. As another route, it could ask for statutory damages of $150,000 per song if it proved willful misuse. That meant a $300,000 cap on that claim, with legal fees sought apart from it.
And GameMill was not the sole target. The suit also named up to 10 unidentified people who may have made or worked on the audio. None of the claims reached a final ruling, given the pending deal.
Elsewhere, LMFP had filed claims against Heritage Auctions, Buckle-Down Inc., and the US Department of the Interior. Two of those disputes led to payments. Buckle-Down agreed to $27,500, and the federal government agreed to $20,000.
Heritage Auctions faced a claim over a social media use of Linus and Lucy, much like Buckle-Down. The government case dealt with Guaraldi's version of O Tannenbaum in an online holiday card. Heritage later got a pause in court deadlines while both sides tried to reach terms.
CBS took a different path. It made a license deal after Linus and Lucy aired during the final episode of The Late Show with Stephen Colbert. Funds from that deal are set for World Central Kitchen, a charity that feeds people in need.
LMFP chairman Jason Mendelson has framed these cases as a push for written music licenses in business use. Attorney Marc Jacobson also made clear that the firm intends to defend the value and rights tied to Guaraldi's work.
One key detail is that Peanuts Worldwide had no role as a defendant. Sony Music Entertainment (Japan) and Sony Pictures Entertainment later gained majority control of its parent, Peanuts Holdings, taking Sony Group's stake from 39% to 80%.
LMFP itself dates back to Lee Mendelson, the late producer behind the Peanuts TV specials. His company remains tied to the music legacy of those shows, though the GameMill deal leaves the main copyright question unanswered.