Suno wants its second copyright case put on ice, and Universal Music Group and Sony Music Entertainment are pushing back hard. The labels fear a full halt could keep fresh claims out of court until 2028, while the AI music firm keeps making money from new models.
At issue are 60,202 tracks that the labels say Suno used for AI training without consent. Each work could carry a penalty of $150,000 if a court finds willful copyright abuse. That puts the total legal risk at more than $9 billion on paper.
Judge F. Dennis Saylor IV has a tricky call here. Suno wants him to deal with fair use and alleged YouTube scraping in the first suit before letting the next one move ahead. A win on those points, Suno argues, could wipe out parts of the newer claims.
Universal and Sony agree that the first ruling matters. But they want a narrower pause, with proof of track rights left for later. The rest of the case, they argue, needs to move while the facts are still fresh.
One major concern is Suno v6. The firm built that model suite with help from Warner, BMG, and Believe, yet the labels claim they still lack key facts about its training. Their first case has records that largely stop at an earlier stage.
And the people who know how the tech works may not stick around. One engineer tied to Suno's data collection has already left, according to the labels. They fear more staff exits could make it harder to learn how each model was built.
Suno says it is keeping key records safe under court rules. It also argues that running two cases at once would waste cash and effort. Fair point to raise, but the labels say stored files cannot replace what former engineers recall.
Their proposed deal would let both sides reuse evidence from the first suit. Suno would share details on model training, license talks, investor pitches, new markets, and its finances. The labels would share data on AI music rights deals and the harm they claim such tracks cause.
If the judge grants a full pause, Universal and Sony want strict data safeguards. That means keeping old model files, training sets, user data, and tech records intact. They also want the case to restart once the first major ruling lands, without waiting for appeals.
The backstory has a few twists. Warner Music Group left the first dispute after a deal with Suno, leaving 560 tracks in that case. Universal and Sony then tried to add 61,026 more, but Saylor rejected the move over the risk of added delays.
Meanwhile, Suno has grown fast. A funding round brought in more than $400 million at a $5.4 billion valuation, while the labels claim its yearly sales reach hundreds of millions. They argue that each delay gives the firm more room to expand.
There's a wider fight over AI music as well. The labels say mass output from such tools can cut into the value of human-made tracks and shrink royalty shares. Suno points to a Justice Department stance that casts doubt on that market harm claim.
Universal and Sony reject the comparison, citing a separate fraud case against Michael Smith. Prosecutors there argued that fake AI tracks took money from a shared royalty pool. The labels say that same payment math matters even without fraud.
Other legal claims add to the pressure. Elvis Presley Enterprises and Eight Mile Style, an Eminem co-publisher, have filed separate suits against Suno. The labels argue that evidence requests in those disputes weaken its complaint about extra work.
For the court, the choice is whether to halt nearly all work or allow a focused review while the first suit plays out. Suno says the claims lack merit, while Universal and Sony want access to newer records. Saylor has yet to settle that fight.
At issue are 60,202 tracks that the labels say Suno used for AI training without consent. Each work could carry a penalty of $150,000 if a court finds willful copyright abuse. That puts the total legal risk at more than $9 billion on paper.
Judge F. Dennis Saylor IV has a tricky call here. Suno wants him to deal with fair use and alleged YouTube scraping in the first suit before letting the next one move ahead. A win on those points, Suno argues, could wipe out parts of the newer claims.
Universal and Sony agree that the first ruling matters. But they want a narrower pause, with proof of track rights left for later. The rest of the case, they argue, needs to move while the facts are still fresh.
One major concern is Suno v6. The firm built that model suite with help from Warner, BMG, and Believe, yet the labels claim they still lack key facts about its training. Their first case has records that largely stop at an earlier stage.
And the people who know how the tech works may not stick around. One engineer tied to Suno's data collection has already left, according to the labels. They fear more staff exits could make it harder to learn how each model was built.
Suno says it is keeping key records safe under court rules. It also argues that running two cases at once would waste cash and effort. Fair point to raise, but the labels say stored files cannot replace what former engineers recall.
Their proposed deal would let both sides reuse evidence from the first suit. Suno would share details on model training, license talks, investor pitches, new markets, and its finances. The labels would share data on AI music rights deals and the harm they claim such tracks cause.
If the judge grants a full pause, Universal and Sony want strict data safeguards. That means keeping old model files, training sets, user data, and tech records intact. They also want the case to restart once the first major ruling lands, without waiting for appeals.
The backstory has a few twists. Warner Music Group left the first dispute after a deal with Suno, leaving 560 tracks in that case. Universal and Sony then tried to add 61,026 more, but Saylor rejected the move over the risk of added delays.
Meanwhile, Suno has grown fast. A funding round brought in more than $400 million at a $5.4 billion valuation, while the labels claim its yearly sales reach hundreds of millions. They argue that each delay gives the firm more room to expand.
There's a wider fight over AI music as well. The labels say mass output from such tools can cut into the value of human-made tracks and shrink royalty shares. Suno points to a Justice Department stance that casts doubt on that market harm claim.
Universal and Sony reject the comparison, citing a separate fraud case against Michael Smith. Prosecutors there argued that fake AI tracks took money from a shared royalty pool. The labels say that same payment math matters even without fraud.
Other legal claims add to the pressure. Elvis Presley Enterprises and Eight Mile Style, an Eminem co-publisher, have filed separate suits against Suno. The labels argue that evidence requests in those disputes weaken its complaint about extra work.
For the court, the choice is whether to halt nearly all work or allow a focused review while the first suit plays out. Suno says the claims lack merit, while Universal and Sony want access to newer records. Saylor has yet to settle that fight.